Download document () of 20
We make what matters work*
Automation Compass HVAC banner

HVAC zone control

Greg - Automation Hub character

Local university upgrading systems to reduce energy consumption costs

Acme University’s building supervisor Greg has been asked to establish a plan to make the institution more energy efficient. Greg first notices that each of the rooms in a specific wing of the campus is being heated at varying temperatures, often higher than needed. Greg contacts his mechanical contractor to determine what adjustments can be made to ensure that controlling the temperature zones in the building is at its highest efficiency level.

Zone control supports more efficient buildings

Zone control is the process of maintaining a specific temperature in a room of a building on-demand according to the needs of the room. In other words, the goal is to supply treated air to destinations in order to meet, but not exceed, the demand required for that room. 

Some rooms in commercial buildings, such as the university’s laboratory, may require that the temperature be a setpoint that isn’t designed for human comfort, but is a controlled environment for experiments to thrive. Whereas others, like classrooms, would require an entirely different environment.

As a result, large HVAC systems are designed to supply heating or cooling throughout a building to several zones while separately control the setpoints for each one.

Illustration of the management of different temperatures in different rooms in a residence
Figure 1: Illustration of the management of different temperatures in different rooms in a residence

Zone control methodologies

Greg has some options for addressing this issue. He can:

  • Use the On/Off method if his application requires basic course control with an acceptable window of tolerance. This is more than sufficient and is the least expensive option
  • Apply Pulse Width Modulation (PWM) where more precise control than the On/Off method is needed. This is a mid-range price option.
  • Apply Proportional, Integral, Derivative (PID) control where precision and accuracy are critical. This is the most expensive, but most commonly used option

What Greg chooses to do is dependent upon what’s happening with the furnace. Let’s dig a bit deeper into these methods.

 

Zone control house

On/Off control

On/Off control is one of the simplest methods for controlling temperature. The basis of this approach is that full power is supplied to the heater until the desired setpoint is achieved. Once the feedback reaches and surpasses the setpoint, the power is completely turned off to the heater. 

When the temperature drops below a bandwidth setpoint, the power will turn back on until the setpoint is reached. This cycle of turning on and off repeats continuously to control the temperature within the desired bandwidth over time.

An illustration of the on-off method of zone control
Figure 2: An illustration of the on-off method of zone control

Pulse Width Modulation (PWM): Variable control

A nano PLC can be used to control the electrical power supplied to an electrical heater in a furnace by using PWM. A variable pulse of full power is supplied to the system. 
The bigger the difference between the setpoint and feedback from a device, the longer the percentage of time the pulse will be on. As the pulses are added together, an average power is supplied to a heater.
Theory of Pulse-Width modulation
Figure 3: Theory of Pulse Width modulation

Proportional, Integral, Derivative (PID): Closed loop control

PID control is a closed loop mathematical function.

It works by:

  • Applying gains to the error, derivative of the error, and integral of the error between the setpoint and feedback
  • It sums those values together, and then outputs the sum to the system as a reference
  • By adjusting the gains, you can adjust the response time, overshoot, and the amount and size of steady state oscillations

An example of how a nano PLC can implement PID control is in its ability to control the position of a damper based on temperature feedback:

  • The error between the setpoint and the feedback from an analog device can be fed into a PID function
  • The output of the PID can then directly control an analog output to a damper position actuator
  • The further the damper is open, the more hot or cold air flows into the room depending on whether you are heating or cooling the room
  • As the temperature fluctuates in a zone, the damper position will dynamically adjust to automatically regulate the temperature
PID for temperature control
Figure 4: PID for temperature control

Pros and cons of each common control methodology

The table below illustrates the implications of applying each methodology using a nano-programmable logic controller. The expectation is that this, plus a deeper understanding of how each works, should provide enough insight into which methodology will work for your needs. We recommend only applying what is needed to manage costs and resources.

Pros and cons of selecting either on/of, PWM or PID control
Figure 5: Pros and cons of selecting either on/of, PWM or PID control
Next Step:

Still have questions? Contact us.